| | First Team |
| Pos. | Name | School |
| P | Jennifer Sexton | Wallace State Community College - Hanceville |
| P | Lindsey Palmer | Salt Lake Community College |
| P | Katelyn Murphree | Santa Fe Community College |
| P | Kristina DeMello | Miami Dade College |
| C | Kelsey Meyers | Iowa Western Community College |
| IF | Rachel Baucom | Wallace State Community College - Hanceville |
| IF | Lauren Lopez | Miami Dade College |
| IF | Jackie Tema | Eastern Arizona College |
| IF | Brooke Walters | Seminole State College |
| IF | Jenna Dell | Iowa Western Community College |
| IF | Kacie Smith | Yavapai College |
| OF | Toni Dance | Iowa Western Community College |
| OF | Brittany Cannon | Santa Fe Community College |
| OF | Caitlin Stangl | Yavapai College |
| OF | Marina Gusman-Brown | Eastern Arizona College |
| DP | Ninostka Amaro | Colby Community College |
| | | |
| | | Second Team |
| Pos. | Name | School |
| P | Holli Hill | Wallace State Community College - Hanceville |
| P | Kelsey McClain | San Jacinto College-South |
| P | Noe Esperas | Eastern Arizona College |
| P | Jenna Rodriguez | Yavapai College |
| C | Brittany Tucker | Yavapai College |
| IF | Geraldine Puertas | Pensacola Junior College |
| IF | Sara Hopwood | Eastern Arizona College |
| IF | Kara Ryman | Western Nebraska Community College |
| IF | Shaunte Duarte | Yavapai College |
| IF | Desiree Mujica | Southeastern Community College |
| IF | Haley Nix | Texarkana College |
| OF | Kristi Kelley | Alvin Community College |
| OF | Karina De Los Santos | Miami Dade College |
| OF | Rebecca Diehl | Garden City Community College |
| OF | Gabrielle Hart | Butler Community College |
| DP | Chambree Pugh | Aiken Technical College |
| | | |
| | | Third Team |
| Pos. | Name | School |
| P | Elena Crabtree | Blinn College |
| P | Lindsey Olson | Galveston College |
| P | Samantha Tiefenthaler | Iowa Western Community College |
| P | Kelsey Garner | Western Nebraska Community College |
| C | Dandi Ammons | Wallace State Community College - Hanceville |
| IF | Christina Jaques | Lamar State College |
| IF | Caley Jeter | Blinn College |
| IF | Hannah Strength | Wallace State Community College - Hanceville |
| IF | Mallory Borden | Santa Fe Community College |
| IF | Casey Saunders | Chattanooga State Technical Community College |
| IF | Jennifer Reifschneider | Pratt Community College |
| OF | Whitney Fox | Navarro College |
| OF | Cheyenne Parent | San Jacinto College-South |
| OF | Kate Vanderham | Florida Community College at Jacksonville |
| OF | Meagan Masingale | Chattanooga State Technical Community College |
| DP | Misti Cosby | Texarkana College |
